I got back 
into D.C. the evening of Saturday, October 13th, and, just 12 hours later, picked up with 
my usual Sunday routine with my dogs and the Sunday papers at Dean and Deluca, albeit 
two hours later than usual. 
Although 
Leben (my male dog) had not recovered even half his walking ability compared to 
where he was before his July 17th surgery (he was walking okay then, 
but walking), we went ahead with the trip 10 weeks after the surgery and weeks 
after the conclusion of the healing period with the vet’s concurrence, qualified 
only by the vet’s moving target for Leben’s recovery from the surgery: first 
four weeks, then eight weeks, then “many months.” It was actually easier for 
Leben and for me to manage him on the road since his walks each day were for the 
most part just a step outside the tent or Land Rover. He was holding his own 
fairly well, although not really recovering 
further.
We set up 
camp in the best sites in seven fantastic Canadian provincial/national parks 
around the Great Lakes , where we were often the 
only campers. We had the wilderness all to ourselves, except for the bears, fox, 
wolves, raccoons, squirrels, and chipmunks. (Not one pesky insect this year.) Of 
course, this was understandable considering that the temperature at night dipped 
to the 20s (we had snow several times) and was rarely above 34 at reveille. (Our 
trip blog was www.ontheroad-2012.blogspot.com)
Unfortunately, three weeks into the 
trip, over a period of three days, I watched Leben struggle to get up, walk, scratch himself with his rear legs, or 
even stay standing on his own. His surgery recovery had failed. He is now 
paralyzed. Since Leben never got back to where he was on the morning before his 
surgery even on the vet’s stretched recovery schedule, my guess is what happened 
is that the vet’s well-intentioned but aggressive, four and a half hour surgery chipped away a lot of 
Leben’s critical mid- and lower-spine nerves and shifted the remaining nerves to 
make them vulnerable to even conservative normal activity, which best describes 
his activity on the trip. This probably would have happened sooner at home 
because conservative normal activity there home would have involved much more 
than he got on the trip. The vet, of course, does not blame the surgery, but a 
fall Leben had on October 3rd. A “chicken and egg” dilemma. (I believe Leben fell because his situation was deteriorating already.) The facts that the 
operation took away Leben’s bladder control, that never advanced beyond the 
half-way point at four weeks, and that a simple fall 10 weeks after the surgery, 
far less than the falls he took in the days after surgery as he tried to walk, 
would cause the paralysis that I hoped to avoid by having the surgery, tell me 
that the operation was not only unsuccessful in improving Leben’s situation or 
preventing any further decline, and, worse, probably set Leben up for paralysis 
sooner. Regardless, I put Leben through the surgery because after reviewing his 
MRI, knowing what happened to two of my prior male German shepherds, Montag and 
Sonntag, and seeing the three steps down Leben had taken over the last two 
years, I was convinced that that Leben would become paralyzed sometime over the 
next year and that there was a decent chance the surgery could avoid that. (I 
also knew that he was a chance that the surgery could “make Leben worse”, as the 
vet told me.) So, Leben is where I expected him to be over the next year without 
the surgery, but at the cost of 10 hellish weeks for him and more than $15,000. 
But if that fall on October 3rd was indeed the cause Leben’s 
paralysis, and that fall would not have taken place at home under conservative 
management, which is doubtful, I have no regrets about taking that journey with 
him and his sister Erde because it was or would have been my last trip with him 
as a walking dog. And what a trooper he was. And who knows? Maybe if he had not 
had the surgery, he might have become paralyzed on the trip 
anyway.
We were 2200 
miles from home in Thunder 
Bay , Ontario 
I am no 
longer concerned about what happened to Leben at or after his surgery, or what 
would have happened without the surgery. He is paralyzed and no one knows what 
his chances are for recovery, if any. I am now concerned only with giving him a 
full life and managing him as a paralyzed dog, which takes six to nine hours a 
day, the latter when I take him swimming three days a week in Middleburg, 
Virginia. My three main goals at this point are to keep up his spirit simply by 
doing everything we did before, albeit differently, to learn how to manage him 
successfully and either stick with that or improve it, and not to neglect his 
magnificent sister, Erde. There are and will be other goals, but those three 
take up a lot of time right now. I hope to keep up this blog about our  new journey for the 
benefit of those who are faced with a similar 
situation.
Despite the 
unwelcome ending to our journey, the ending could have been worse. And nothing 
will detract from the absolutely extraordinary trip it was in so many respects, 
for all of us, including Leben. This one for sure will turn out to have been a 
life-changer. One life-change that I know for sure is that I will never subject 
any dog of mine to spinal surgery again, having struck out three times now, 
once, in Leben’s case, where the dog came out worse than when he went in. In the 
future, I will wait until paralysis occurs and then go immediately to a 
wheelchair. Sonntag led a full, active life in his wheelchair for three and a 
half years. Leben is about to do the same for his full life. Why the vets do not 
suggest this as an option I do not know.  Why I did not chose that option myself 
with Sonntag and now with Leben, I also do not know. But that it no longer a 
concern of mine either.
